Valuing multiple ecosystem services under contrasting land use scenarios

Author(s): Ellen Audia, Lisa Schulte Moore, John Tyndall
Abstract:

While provisioning ecosystem services generated through agricultural production are high, this often comes at the expense of other ecosystem services. Approaches that support both farm income and a balanced array of ecosystem services are needed. We employed a landscape modeling approach to demonstrate the financial and ecosystem service outcomes of strategically restoring grassland cover within a Corn Belt agricultural watershed. We assessed potential changes associated with a “Baseline” land use scenario and two alternative scenarios for the Grand River Basin (Iowa and Missouri, USA). In a “Buffered” scenario we simulated the impacts of replacing cropland within 20 m of streams with restored native grassland cover. In a “Productivity-based” scenario we simulated the replacement of annual row crops on poorly performing croplands with native grassland cover. Grasslands comprised 0.4% of the Baseline scenario. Grassland was expanded to 0.8% of the watershed in the Buffered scenario, reducing annual nutrient and sediment loss by 1.44%, increasing soil carbon sequestration by 0.12% over 10 years, and increasing pollinator abundance by 0.01%. The estimated annual value of these enhancements was $1.7 million for nitrogen reduction, $0.1 million for phosphorus reduction, $0.5 million for sediment reduction, and $1.3 million for soil carbon sequestration. Grassland comprised 4.9% of the watershed in the Productivity-based scenario, reduced annual nutrient and sediment loss by 11.50%, increased soil carbon sequestration by 1.13% over 10 years, and increased pollinator abundance by 0.42%. The estimated annual value of enhancements was $18 million for nitrogen reduction, $1.4 million for phosphorus reduction, $2.5 million for sediment reduction, and $14 million for soil carbon sequestration. We also calculated the value of grassland biomass for a potential energy market. The benefit of producing and selling grassland biomass ranged -$445 to $1,291 ha−1 yr−1. Scaled to the watershed, annual revenues ranged -$7.3 million to $21.1 million for the Buffered scenario and -$44.2 million to $128.8 million for the Productivity-based scenario. This study was the first to quantify changes in revenue and the value of ecosystem services associated with grassland restoration in the Grand River Basin and can help inform discussion among watershed stakeholders.

Funder: Iowa State University Presidential Interdisciplinary Research Initiative
Award Title:
Vice President of Research Presidential Interdisciplinary Research Initiative for the Consortium for Cultivating Human And Naturally reGenerative Enterprises
Award Number: PG110214
Keywords:
bioenergy, continuous living cover, environmental benefits, InVEST, natural resources economics, perennial agriculture, water quality
Project (Abbreviated name):
G2G_Schulte_valuing_ecosystem_services
Team: Grass2Gas
Geographic Location:
The Grand River watershed in S. Iowa and N. Missouri
Families:
Apidae, Halictidae, Nymphalidae
Species:
Danaus plexippus
Data Table Column Names and Descriptions
Table nameColumn nameData typeUnitsColumn description
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolsc abovefloatNACarbon stored above ground.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolsc belowfloatNACarbon stored below ground.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolsc deadfloatNACarbon stored in dead organic matter.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolsc soilfloatNACarbon stored in soil.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolscarbon models carbon pools pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolscountfloatnumberNumber of pixels of each land cover type.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolslucodefloatnumberNumerical code representing each land cover type.
data.carbon_models_carbon_poolsnlcd landstringNADescription or type of land cover.
data.enterprise_budgetcost typestringNAThe source of the cost or type of activity accruing cost.
data.enterprise_budgetcostsstringNASpecific cost activity.
data.enterprise_budgetenterprise budget pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.enterprise_budgetmean price dollars per acfloatNAThe average cost of the activity per acre.
data.enterprise_budgetnotesstringNAExtra information for each activity.
data.enterprise_budgetrange of costsstringNAThe range of costs/unit of each activity.
data.enterprise_budgetsource of price informationstringNAThe source of the cost information.
data.enterprise_budgetstepsstringNAThe steps needed for the activity.
data.enterprise_budgetyear cost incurredstringNAThe year the cost is expected to occur.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablecountfloatnumberNumber of pixels of each land cover type.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablecrit len nfloatmeterThe distance after which it is assumed that this LULC type retains the nutrient at its maximum capacity.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablecrit len pfloatmeterThe distance after which it is assumed that this LULC type retains phosphorous at its maximum capacity.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tableeff nfloatNAMaximum nutrient retention efficiency.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tableeff pfloatNAMaximum phosphorous retention efficiency.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tableload nfloatNAThe nutrient loading for each land use class.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tableload pfloatNAThe phosphorous loading for each land use class.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablelucodefloatnumberNumerical code representing each land cover type.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablenlcd landstringNADescription or type of land cover.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tablenutrient model biophysical table pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.nutrient_model_biophysical_tableproportion subsurface nfloatNAThe proportion of the total amount of nitrogen that are dissolved into the subsurface.
data.pollination_guild_tablealphafloatmeterForaging range.
data.pollination_guild_tableforaging activity fall indexfloatdimensionlessIndex indicating the degree of foraging activity in the fall.
data.pollination_guild_tableforaging activity spring indexfloatdimensionlessIndex indicating the degree of foraging activity in the spring.
data.pollination_guild_tableforaging activity summer indexfloatdimensionlessIndex indicating the degree of foraging activity in the summer.
data.pollination_guild_tablenesting suitability cavity indexstringNAIndex that indicates if the species nests in cavities.
data.pollination_guild_tablenesting suitability ground indexstringNAIndex that indicates if the species nests in the ground.
data.pollination_guild_tablenesting suitability milkweed indexstringNAIndex that indicates if the species uses milkweed for nesting.
data.pollination_guild_tablepollination guild table pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.pollination_guild_tablerelative abundancefloatNAThe proportion of total pollinator abundance that consists of this species.
data.pollination_guild_tablespeciesstringNAThe species being modeled.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablecountfloatnumberNumber of pixels of each land cover type.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablefloral resources fall indexfloatdimensionlessFloral resources for each land cover type in the fall.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablefloral resources spring indexfloatdimensionlessFloral resources for each land cover type in the spring.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablefloral resources summer indexfloatdimensionlessFloral resources for each land cover type in the summer.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablelucodefloatnumberNumerical code representing each land cover type.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablenesting cavity availability indexfloatdimensionlessAvailability of land cover for pollinator nesting cavities.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablenesting ground availability indexfloatdimensionlessAvailability of land cover for pollinator ground nesting.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablenesting milkweed availability indexfloatdimensionlessAvailability milkweed in each land cover type.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablenlcd landstringNADescription or type of land cover.
data.pollinator_model_biophysical_tablepollinator model biophysical table pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tablec normfloatdimensionlessUncalibrated crop or management practice factor in soil loss equation.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tablelucodefloatnumberNumerical code representing each land cover type.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tablenlcd landstringNADescription or type of land cover.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tablep normfloatdimensionlessUncalibrated support practice factor in soil loss equation.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tablesediment model biophysical table pkeyfloatnumberA unique primary key for this table.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tableusle cfloatdimensionlessCalibrated crop or management practice factor in soil loss equation.
data.sediment_model_biophysical_tableusle pfloatdimensionlessCalibrated support practice factor in soil loss equation.